This photo appears to have been cut out of a cabinet card, which made me wonder if this is Julia E, daughter of Vincent and Ellen Joy? There is no photographer information. But, looking back at what Iggy found about the family, Julia E was born most likely in 1868 and the cabinet card hadn’t yet come into it’s time. This child is around 1 1/2 to 2 years of age, so maybe it could be Julia E, maybe not. There was also some weirdness that took place between Vincent Joy and his older sister Malinda’s step children.
It appears that Malinda Joy married Charles Chappelear and had 6 children. Charles passed away from illness shortly after serving in the US Army in the Civil War. Somehow after this, Malinda, Vincent and a man named Martin Wachtel became acquainted. Martin was a widower with a young daughter, Elizabeth Ellen. So Vincent and Ellen became acquainted and married in 1865. In 1867 Martin and Malinda married. Later on in 1868, Vincent became the guardian of the Chappelear children for some reason. It is possible this little girl is part of that family somehow. Very confusing!